| 1902–1905 | Herman G. Possner | 1966 | Edward W. Bouclin |
| 1906 | George R. Babbitt | 1967 | Clayton D. Lanphear, Jr. |
| 1907 | A.T. Scattergood | 1968 | William W. Whitfield |
| 1908 | S.M. Holman | 1969 | Wilber F. Abbott |
| 1909 | Zenas W. Bliss | 1970 | Richard E. Nickerson |
| 1910–1911 | Dutee W. Flint | 1971 | Gerard H.G. Forman |
| 1912 | Fred W. Bartels | 1972–1973 | Anthony Chemel |
| 1913–1914 | William H. Draper | 1974 | Sanford J. Sachs |
| 1915 | George J. Kelley | 1975–1976 | L. Angell |
| 1916 | Dutee W. Flint | 1977 | William F. Plumb |
| 1917 | D.A. Sayre | 1978 | Norman G. Orodenker |
| 1918 | H.S. Wolfe | 1979 | Henry E. Childers |
| 1919–1921 | D.A. Sayre | 1980–1981 | Hayes, Jr. |
| 1922 | Oliver D. Edwards | 1982 | Fredrick J. Darby |
| 1923 | F.C. Church | 1983 | Neil E. Jacques |
| 1924–1927 | W.L. Chapman | 1984 | John D. Biafore |
| 1928 | Alexander R. Fritz | 1985–1986 | . McDonald |
| 1929 | Llewellyn C. Roffee | 1987–1988 | Donald F. Ihlefeld |
| 1930 | C.A. Hallberg | 1989 | Patrick J. Hurley |
| 1931–1932 | Stuart Bastow | 1990–1991 | Benjamin G. Paster |
| 1933–1934 | Murray S. Upham | 1992 | Robert J. McKeon |
| 1935–1936 | Arthur W. Coffin | 1993 | Richard L. Stewart |
| 1937–1938 | Douglas H. Paton | 1994–1995 | Dennis P. Egan |
| 1939 | Stanley G. Cady | 1996 | Roland G. Alix |
| 1940–1941 | Leon E. Nickerson | 1997–1998 | Donald H. DeRoche |
| 1942–1943 | Harry F. Livezey | 1999 | Michael Hardiman |
| 1944 | Wlater E. Winters | 2000 | Edith Jourdan-Grittner |
| 1945 | Russell R. Hunt | 2001 | Edwin H. Benz |
| 1946 | Edson W. Sawyer | 2002 | Wayne Marcus |
| 1947–1948 | Gordon E. Shepard | 2003 | Andrew B. Burkhardt |
| 1949–1950 | Leon W. Brower | 2004 | Norman L. Proulx |
| 1951 | Alvin S. Clegg | 2005 | John A. McDonough |
| 1952 | Clinton C. Brady | 2006 | Scott W. Duckworth |
| 1953–1954 | James B. Dow | 2007 | Theo Aschman |
| 1955–1956 | Ralph S. Haefele | 2008–2009 | Jeff Partington |
| 1957–1958 | William S. Ellis | 2010 | Deborah Wloch |
| 1959–1960 | Charles C. Plumb, Jr. | 2011-2012 | Jeff Lanphear |
| 1961–1962 | Fredrick J. Darby | 2013 | Marie DeRoche |
| 1963 | Charles J. Davis, Jr. | 2014-2016 | Wayne Kezirian |
| 1964–1965 | Leonard C. Upham | 2017-2019 |
Flo Spenard |
Current Commodore is Renee Lemay 2019 –